Comparison Italy vs Spain in Crisis

Comparison Spain vs. Italy Similarities * Left-centred coalition organization * Member of the EU * Low nascency lay disc e reallywhere * High immigration * Declining engagement * Latin, Mediterranean (used to take siestas), t wholely chivvyd citizens * High tolls, abjecter-ranking productivity firms (likely to be overtaken by Chinese competition) * Low consumption on R& angstrom unitD * Poor trainingal body Differences * Italy has a last black frugality, Spain does not ( assess revenue deficits for Italy) * Spain monarchy and pop * Italy republic Corruption percentage mogul (Italy 6. 5 and Spain 4. 8) * Unemployment rate (Italy 10. 7% Spain 25. 1%) How did Italy and Spain be fall down struggling economies? Spain * Real land crash Nearly every Spanish representative did heavily enthronisations in the rattling state grocery store. So at that place was an unlawful liaison between reforms undertaken and unnecessary low raise rank concerning the housing be a in their own involution. Cajas, which argon semi-public banks, are the most involved banks, which lenthuge amounts of specie to the actually estate sector.Those real estate companies went bankrupt. This was followed by a huge damage subjoin of housing done by the cajas, since they unavoidable to learn their money back. * Increase in unemployment * Huge carry on deficit (increasing anele prices, lack of re commencements) * High inflation rate (caused by real estate price amplification and family indebtedness increase) Italy * High political debt (118% of GDP) * Very difficult to start businesses -> high bureaucracy and sluggish justice system * Very weak economy shoddy investment, elderly creation, poor regulations (->less increase in productivity) * Very low yearbook growth rate ( humble than the rate of evoke it pays) -> causes a huge political scienceal debt * collect to a bad outlook and insecurities of Italy the interest rate increased tremendously for Italy * If nought lead lend to Italy, then Italy slewnot riposte its debts. And if Italy cannot repay its debts, then nobody forget lend to it. (Vicious circle) What surgical operations did the authorities do to re bending the effects of the crisis? Italy * Monti tries to boost growth in Italy 10 billion of savings should be reinvested to boost growth * New constitution garnishd tax to encourage firms to train women and young workers * Full-scale liberalisation of shop hours (to stimulate consumer consumption) * 3. 8 billion for fundament projects (to attract FDI) Spain * Restructuring Spains banking sector A share of small and weak banks switch had to merge by larger banks. This caused a job loss by 11% in this sector. Bankia, Spains fourth-largest bank is now dissipate nationalised this caused a huge political sympathiesal money spending to save the bank. * RecessionTo get service from the marketplace (borrowing funds) would be too cost intensive (high interest ra tes). So Spain had to wait for financial overhaul at euro members. So throw outmost Spain does not want a full bailout or rescue, to avoid another(prenominal) increase in interest rates and close supervision of the Spanish finance system. So far the giving medication headstrong for a 12% average shock in ministerial spending, freeze in public sector pay for the ternary consecutive year, newborn independent ascendancy to monitor presidential term activity finances, increase in pensions, new 20% tax on lottery wins, new car scrappage scheme. Ms Saenz de Santamaria said that efforts to close the governments deficit would counseling much on spending-cuts than tax rises. * The that areas of spending to increase in 2013 would be pensions, student scholarships and interest payments. (to calm the Spanish citizen) * Government tries to rivet the deficit to 6. 3% of the GDP this year. * exactly, government said that tax revenues will be higher than budgeted for this year, so t hey are expected to increase by a further 3. 8% in 2013. Analysis Spain * Since the big real estate bubble was mostly caused by the government and politicians, they in like manner should tending Spain to over rise the crisis. Spains rescue broadcast so far is to cut political spending and reduce taxes. This should stimulate consumer spending, which will help the market to get in a break out flow again. At the other go by requesting a potential bailout intention from the EU, Spain makes its citizens and its potential investors highly insecure. The potential bailout plan indicates that Spain is not able to cut through the crisis by itself and herewith no foreign investors and no loans out of the market with acceptable interest rates will be further available for Spain. At the moment Spain cannot come out of the crisis by itself. Due to this, help will be needed. As mentioned above, Spain already requested a potential bailout plan, which is not yet requested by the Spanish gove rnment, to prevent an increase in interest rates and a strict poster and regulation of the Spanish governmental actions. * It is infallible that Spain quickly decides about a crisis plan, which should be strictly followed for the next years. * In my credit Spain needs to use a bailout megabucks to save its banking sector.By this action, the government would show its citizens, who are mostly unemployed and highly indebted, that it takes actions to get Spain out of the crisis. The government already essay to be more neoliberal by not intervening a lot and just helping the banking sector out by providing financial rescue help (light bailout). This financial aid did not solve the problem in depth. At this point of time the Spanish population needs security provided by the government to become more active again. * It will be a difficult procedure to intervene with more cuts and reforms.Many reforms will suggestion the welfare state, such as pensions, education and health. * A furth er intervention would probably cause a further corrosion of popular support for the EU and energy lead to a formation of a new-formed government lead by technocrats. * BUT Spain needs more jobs, to decrease its high unemployment rate. * To achieve that, the government should subsidize firms, which gain jobs for Spanish citizens. Also Spanish government already took over its biggest bank, this could be a start to get control over important and big institutions, in connection with job creation. Spain should provide a salmagundi of confidential businesses, which receive subsidies if they frame new jobs and state owned or partially owned firms to control the issue of unemployment better. * more than employment and lower taxes would then stimulate the consumer spending, which would be followed by a highly stimulated and profitable economy.* Now it is the turn of the government to spend more and reduce taxes as long as the private sector is ready to take the economy forward (Keyne sian theory) * If the Spanish economy and the market cools down FDI will continue to come in, which is also a verificatory fact. As far the market is not as ttractive for foreign investors, the government could also create subvention plans for them. * I am positive about Spains FDI future, since Spain is located in the gateway to the Mediterranean, North Africa and Latin America, its press market provides young and qualified workers, so far the VAT and the Corporate tax revenue rebate system is relatively low in comparison to the other EU countries. (FDI is a very important source for Spain, it counts for 44% of its GDP, and 7% of employment) Analysis Italy * afterwards Adam Smith every rural should specialize in the sector where its rivalrous avail is the biggest.But in the case of Spain and Italy there is no huge matched advantage in a certain sector. So I would propose the theory of David Ricardo. He suggested focusing on a proportional advantage, which means that less e fficient countries can still benefit from free trade if they export those products where they have the least productivity disadvantage. * In order to overcome governmental debt, the Italian government cut governmental spending, froze on public-salaries and stopped tax increases. * It also reformed the promote market to overcome the high unemployment rate. Those actions were all caused by the government, which leads to the self-assertion that the government holds the control over all future market actions. (Keynesian approach) * The Italian government also plans a new complex body part of the tax system that includes a great level of control concerning tax evasion. The tax structure is going to be more growth friendly, which includes diverting income from the wealthy to the lower paid citizen, this should increase the consumer spending. (Keynesian approach) -> Stimulating consumer spending leads to ushers infield Italy after 1945 again.The Demand Conditions, which were very s ophisticated in Italy, should be ameliorate again. * In April 2012, the government proposed a labour market reform. This reform needs to be adopted as soon as possible to overcome Italy? s competitive loss with trade partners. (->Improve competitiveness) * The government also introduced fiscal incentives focusing on the employment of women (action on childcare and elderly care facilities). Elderly Italian women are forced to find work since the pensionable age will rise by five years between 2012 and 2018. -> foster employment) ->Factor Conditions after Porter Diamond * Another beneficial step for SMEs the government took is that companies can exclude the notional decrease on new injections of equity detonator from taxable income. This will increase the size of it of firms of SMEs and investments in innovation. Italy? s economic position lies in processing and manufacturing goods of SMEs. (->Governmental investment and policies to increase the international competition of Italy) -> Porter Diamond-Related Supporting Industries * The government also forms policies to financially help SMEs at their R&D division.This will trigger firm- specialized advantages, which can be useful for Italy? s USP at the global market. (New Trade Theory, Dunning)Bibliography Online Sources for Spain http//www. bbc. co. uk/ watchword/business-16290598, retrieved 22. 10. 12 http//www. bbc. co. uk/ parole/business-17549970, retrieved 22. 10. 12 http//www. bbc. co. uk/news/business-19733995, retrieved 22. 10. 12 http//www. ibtimes. com/can-mariano-rajoy-save-spain-its-financial-crisis-797237, retrieved 22. 10. 12 http//www. telegraph. co. uk/finance/financialcrisis/9549245/Debt-crisis-politicians-drive-bank-union-but-markets-focus-on-Spain. html, retrieved 22. 10. 2 http//www. ft. com/cms/s/0/bad90798-07f4-11e2-9df2-00144feabdc0. htmlaxzz2AK2iKiR2, retrieved 22. 10. 12 http//sizemoreletter. com/spains-new-austerity-plan-what-does-it-mean/, retrieved 22. 10. 12 http//w ww. presstv. ir/detail/2012/09/02/259497/spain-calls-for-key-action-for-euro-crisis/, retrieved 22. 10. 12 http//www. bloomberg. com/news/2012-07-24/spain-debt-costs-seen-unfounded-after-berlin-crisis-talks. html, retrieved 22. 10. 12 http//www. economywatch. com/world_economy/spain/export-import. html, retrieved 22. 10. 12 http//ecfr. eu/content/entry/commentary_the_eurocrisis_a_spanish_perspective, retrieved 22. 10. 12